Not Peace but Division

by Mike Ratliff

“Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. And a person’s enemies will be those of his own household.” (Matthew 10:34-36 ESV)

The number one accusation against those who proclaim the truth from God’s Word in the face of apostasy is that they are being divisive. I believe we should seek to have peace with all men, but we must be prepared to encounter conflict with those who refuse to submit to God’s truth. We are never called to be at peace with false teachers or false prophets or apostates.

From Jesus’ own teachings we learn that the cost of being His disciple is very high. Grace is free, but becoming a disciple of Jesus Christ costs us everything. We are told that no one is worthy of the Kingdom of God who is in love with this world. We cannot serve God correctly if we love our own life more than Him. We cannot love our families more than Him. We cannot love possessions more than Him. We are called to be the interim or peacemaker between those whom we love and God. We are to be the one God uses to bring them into the Kingdom. However, we are also called to not waiver and turn our backs on God and His ways because pressure is put on us to compromise our walk with God for the sake of peace.

“I came to cast fire on the earth, and would that it were already kindled! I have a baptism to be baptized with, and how great is my distress until it is accomplish” (Luke 12:49-51 ESV)

Jesus came to cast fire on the earth. This statement by our Lord is speaking of judgment. John the Baptist made the following statement about Jesus Christ.

“I baptize you with water for repentance, but he who is coming after me is mightier than I, whose sandals I am not worthy to carry. He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire. His winnowing fork is in his hand, and he will clear his threshing floor and gather his wheat into the barn, but the chaff he will burn with unquenchable fire.” (Matthew 3:11-12 ESV)

John the Baptist used three references to Baptism in this passage. The first was “water for repentance.” This is what John the Baptist’s role was. His baptism symbolized cleansing. It was for those who were being baptized to show their commitment to repentance. The second was “baptize you with the Holy Spirit…” This signified that all genuine believers in our Lord Jesus Christ are Spirit-baptized. They receive the Holy Spirit indwelling them. No one without Him is genuine. The third baptism is with “fire.” This is referring to the baptism of judgment upon all the unrepentant.

Notice also that John tells us that in this our Lord will use His winnowing fork in His hand. What does that mean? This was a tool used for tossing grain into the wind so that the chaff is separated from it and blown away. This is speaking of separating those who have been baptized with the Holy Spirit from those who are to be baptized by fire. The grain signifies genuine disciples of our Lord Jesus Christ while the chaff represents unbelievers. The grain is gathered into barns, but the chaff is burned with a fire that is never quenched.

If we look back at Luke 12:49-51, we see that Jesus deeply desired for this unquenchable fire to be already kindled. He then states that He has a baptism to be baptized with. His baptism was one of suffering. This is referring to his suffering and death on the cross. When a new believer is baptized, the ceremony symbolizes identification with Him in death, burial, and resurrection. Jesus stated that he was in great distress until His baptism this was completed.

Why was Jesus in distress about going to the cross? Was He afraid of the beatings or the nails in His flesh or death? No, He knew that while on the cross that all of God’s fury and judgment against sin would be poured out on Him. He would endure God’s wrath against our sin.

“Do you think that I have come to give peace on earth? No, I tell you, but rather division. For from now on in one house there will be five divided, three against two and two against three. They will be divided, father against son and son against father, mother against daughter and daughter against mother, mother-in-law against her daughter-in-law and daughter-in-law against mother-in-law.”” (Luke 12:51-53 ESV)

Again, our Lord tells us that through His work on the cross there would be two groups of people. One group is made up of His disciples. The other group is everyone else. This “division” will run through families, cities, nations, churches, you name it. No matter where we go in this world, no matter what groups we are part of; those groups will contain some from both divisions. As a result, along with the natural conflict that goes on through the works of sinful men everywhere, there will be a supernatural division between our Lord’s flock and the rest of the world. This division will not be peaceful. It takes many forms. There is outright persecution in some situations. However, some of the worst conflict here comes when non-believers insist on being part of our Lord’s flock on their own merit.

Despite the efforts of those who try to be at peace with apostates, our Lord knows better. He knows who is bound for the fire and who is bound for the barn. However, we do not. That is why we must be very careful whom we accept as a brother in sister in Christ. We do no one any favors if we blindly accept everyone’s testimony without careful observation. If we give people false hope then we have done more harm than good.

What about families divided by the cross? I know that many reading this have loved ones that believe they are Christians because of their works, or what church they belong to, etc. What are we to do? We must never stop being peacemakers. (Matthew 5:9) We pray for them continually. We witness to them every chance we get. When war breaks out over the division we always seek to leave a door open in which to do our peace work.

What about apostates who demand to be seen as genuine? If you look closely at these people, you will see that they have made up their own version of Christianity that is self-focused and temporal in nature. We must never allow anyone to proclaim a false version of the Gospel to be proclaimed as genuine. We must never allow anyone to twist our Lord’s words or the Bible’s words to make them say what they do not say. How are we to confront them? We must do so only from the basis of truth from God’s Word. That is why I do not allow debate on this blog unless all arguments are based in scripture. Personal and Straw Man attacks are not allowed. Instead, we use God’s Word to simply proclaim the truth. If any change is to be made in these people it will only come through the working of the Holy Spirit in them, not by our arguing.


16 thoughts on “Not Peace but Division

  1. The problem with the lost, “everyone else”, false teachers, apostates and their supporters is: “the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness” and they can not understand any argument or reasoning from scripture. In fact they will turn the meaning of scriptures around in a 180 degree spin.

    And, if you are truly dealing with apostates Hebrews 6:4-6 gives tham no hope “to renew them again to repentance”, so arguing/reasoning with them even in love is indeed a waste of time.

    It’s best not to argue, but spend that time in prayer that the Lord will draw them to Himself and the Holy Spirit will open their hearts and eyes that they may be humbled before God, repent and find salvation. Since only our Lord knows the heart and where it stands before Him, we must we present the Word and pray for those that oppose that truth.


  2. I still don’t understand how a God so many proclaim to be all loving will cast those who rebel against Him into the pits of hell for all eternity. Granted, I know the parent comparison, even parents who love their children will punish them should the children disobey their orders. What I understand is that the parents will eventually re-embrace their children back into their arms and continue to love them. Yet, what about God? Eternal damnation even if we don’t ask for the forgiveness of minute sin the person made just before being taken out by a bus (for example)? Please, do not just explain, but give me passages from your bible to back up your claims, and please no one-liners. I want passages.


  3. hear hear Mike. Hear hear Rick.

    “We are never called to be at peace with false teachers or false prophets or apostates.”

    Bingo… I spent too many years wringing my hands and feeling so horrible about myself and the more I walked on eggshells the more people didn’t seem to care that I was being ‘careful’ for them.

    So… forget it. I am going to listen to the Lord now, and speak the truth in season and out. I came from a relatively short (6 yr) excursion into the Evangelical Covenant denomination which seems to produce almost nothing but passive men, and no leadership except into the ways of error and apostasy.

    Yeah… they’re big promoters of emergent, contemplative, social gospel, purpose driven, and every other popular error. Absolutely oppressive.


  4. Jersey…
    First of all, a person who has accepted Jesus Christ as his/ her personal Savior, and Lord of his/her life, has forgiveness for all sins, both past and present. There is no need to “confess” a sin right before death, in order to escape hell.
    In response to your other question, let me share with you that I had the same thoughts about eternal punishment for sin. Sin has eternal consequences…thus eternal punishment is just. My own life shows this: my father ( and his parents) cast my mother out onto the street, before I was born. They kept all her personal belongings, and court documents show that she didn’t have enough food, or clothing. The effects on the life of my mother, siblings, and the rest of the family have endured down through the years, and although I am “saved” by the Grace of God, for eternity I will experience the effect that action has had on my own life, and person. If you have watched the movie “It’s a Wonderful Life” this Christmas season, you may see how the actions of people affect others, and even their whole life.
    Please read the references Mike has given you, and trust Jesus Christ to save you from your sins, and their consequences. He saved me from mine, and helped me in more ways than I can explain here.


  5. Jersey – sin brings death, not that God is actually bringing death personally to each sinner, He doesn’t have to, sin itself brings spiritual death. Imagine two people wlking toward a cliff, one is Charles Manson and another is a two year old toddler. Neither see the cliff and they both fall off it unto their deaths.

    Is that fair? We would not feel bad about Manson but we would feel the child’s death was unfair. But gravity makes no distinction concerning fairness, all who fall off that cliff will die at gravity’s hands without distinction. And so it is with sin, the soul that sins it shall die, without distiction or comparison. And there is only one payment for sin and that is Christ. He who receives Christ’s death as his own payment for sin will live forever.

    And Jersey, surely that is the most unfair of all, no?


  6. Here is a definition of “evangelical Christian” :

    An Evangelical Christian holds these six distinctives.

    1) The supreme authority of Scripture
    2) Jesus Christ as incarnate God
    3) the Holy Spirit
    4) personal conversion
    5) evangelism
    6) the importance of the Christian community

    I believe in all of these along with the importance of Biblical scholarship. Of course others may have other definitions. Some Christians don’t share the gospel, but I believe we should. In my own way of thinking, we are all called to hold to these things and be ready to share our faith as led by God.

    In Christ

    Mike Ratliff


Comments are closed.