Judge With Right Judgment

by Mike Ratliff

Do not judge by appearances, but judge with right judgment.” (John 7:24 ESV)

What is the definition of the English word “fact?” The following is from the Merriam Webster Online Dictionary.

Main Entry: fact

Pronunciation: \ˈfakt\

Function: noun

Etymology: Latin factum, from neuter of factus, past participle of facere

Date: 15th century

1 : a thing done: as a obsolete : feat b : crime <accessory after the fact> c archaic : action 2 archaic : performance, doing 3 : the quality of being actual : actuality <a question of fact hinges on evidence>
4 a : something that has actual existence <space exploration is now a fact> b : an actual occurrence <prove the fact of damage>
5 : a piece of information presented as having objective reality

in fact : in truth

The part that says, “a piece of information presented as having objective reality” is where I would like to concentrate in this post. I am a firm believer that there is something called absolute truth. Also, there exist truths that are objective. These are facts. On the other hand, there is information that is subjective in nature that is presented as if it has objective reality when actually this is not so because there is nothing objective behind the “proof.” For instance, there are times when I use a form of the word “purpose” in what I write to convey a truth of God “purposing” to do something or that as Christians we should purpose in our hearts to obey the Lord, et cetera. There are some who would attempt to make the case that this is “Purpose Driven” language and this “proves” that I have become compromised and am now a disciple of Rick Warren. I contend that this type of thinking is what our Lord was referring to in John 7:24 about judging by appearances.

A fact is something that actually possesses objective reality. It can be proven. When I teach that God is Omnipotent, Omniscient, Omnipresent, and Immutable, I use Sacred Scripture as proof. These truths are clearly taught in the Bible. When I or one of my good friends writes about Rick Warren or Bill Hybels and what they say that is unbiblical we give you what they have said and compare it with what the Bible says about that topic. This is how we expose the false. On the other hand, if we attempted to prove that a pastor, theologian or Christian writer was false or was compromised and the only evidence we had was akin to the example I used above about the use of the word “purpose” then what we have done is given you not objective, but subjective reasoning. When we do this we are doing judging by appearances and are leading you to do the same thing, hoping you will “make the connection” that we have subjectively made.

When I think of the subjective I always go back to some team sports I played as a boy and teenager in which the umpires or referees would make calls that most of us knew very well were not based on facts, but on a judgment call by the man who was really only going on a split second glimpse of evidence of something that may or may not have really taken place. When I was in the US Navy, I was recruited to play as a replacement player on a military touch football team that played other military teams within our city. There was only one referee, but he wore the whole getup with the stripped shirt and white hat. I played defense. On one play, I tipped a pass that was intercepted by one our defensive backs. When this happened I was facing away from the line of scrimmage. When the pass was intercepted, I turned to block for the one who had caught it. That is all I did. I just turned around and bumped into a player on the other team. By then, our guy had passed us and was on the way to the end zone. We celebrated. Then the referee called the play back, pointed his finger at me and said I had clipped (blocked from behind) on the play. I got in his face while the one I had supposedly blocked illegally was laughing his guts out. He had pretended to be blocked in the back by me when I really only bumped him face to face then stepped around him. I became so angry that I told the one who had recruited me that I was done and left to sit out the rest of the game.

I have been receiving “proof” from a person claiming that it clearly shows that John MacArthur and his ministries are purpose driven and that John himself is not really a Christian. I asked for the proof. What I got was a great deal of subjective evidence based on the guilt by association and amphiboly logical fallacies. There was nothing that could even remotely be called objective reality in any of it. With each rejection, I would receive more data. Finally, the person feeding me the “evidence” proclaimed that I was guilty of being what the social-psychologists call a “transformational thinker. He then claimed, “You can’t attend to facts. You change facts to opinions and innuendo.” Well, you know me, I had to look up that one. This is an accusation that I am in league with Rick Warren, Bill Hybels and am a “Change Agent” like them. When confronted by “the truth” I turn it to merely opinion and innuendo because, in this way, I can lie to people, pretending to be one thing, but am actually in league with the very people who are decimating our Churches with the Purpose Driven deception. In other words, he accused me of being a lying hypocrite. Our Lord was accused of much worse than that.

But after his brothers had gone up to the feast, then he also went up, not publicly but in private. The Jews were looking for him at the feast, and saying, “Where is he?” And there was much muttering about him among the people. While some said, “He is a good man,” others said, “No, he is leading the people astray.” Yet for fear of the Jews no one spoke openly of him. About the middle of the feast Jesus went up into the temple and began teaching. The Jews therefore marveled, saying, “How is it that this man has learning, when he has never studied?” So Jesus answered them, “My teaching is not mine, but his who sent me. If anyone’s will is to do God’s will, he will know whether the teaching is from God or whether I am speaking on my own authority. The one who speaks on his own authority seeks his own glory, but the one who seeks the glory of him who sent him is true, and in him there is no falsehood. Has not Moses given you the law? Yet none of you keeps the law. Why do you seek to kill me?” The crowd answered, “You have a demon! Who is seeking to kill you?” Jesus answered them, “I did one deed, and you all marvel at it. Moses gave you circumcision (not that it is from Moses, but from the fathers), and you circumcise a man on the Sabbath. If on the Sabbath a man receives circumcision, so that the law of Moses may not be broken, are you angry with me because on the Sabbath I made a man’s whole body well? Do not judge by appearances, but judge with right judgment.” (John 7:10-24 ESV)

Here is the Koine Greek of v24 (the line in bold above).

μη κρινετε κατ οψιν αλλα την δικαιαν κρισιν κρινετε

This literally says, “Not judge according to sight, but the right judgment judge.” The word translated as judge is κρινετε. The words “according to sight” are κατ οψιν. Κρινετε refers to the act of dividing, separating, making a distinction, or coming to a decision. Jesus said to not do that κατ οψιν. What does it mean to judge by sight or appearances? The word κατ (according to) in this context is metamorphically being used of the κρινετε being made according to or in respect to οψιν, which refers to the outside or countenance rather than the inner character or truth. Jesus tells us here to not make our judgments based on the subjective, ever! Instead, we are to κρινετε only with την δικαιαν κρισιν, “the right judgment. “ The word δικαιαν refers to that which is right according to God’s standards, which are just and good according to His character.

The word κρισιν, judgment, is a separation, sundering, judgment, or sentence. We are not commanded to never judge here, but to judge only according to God’s judgment. This means that we will not use subjective reasoning, but will compare what the one under scrutiny says and does, comparing those things with God’s standards. This means that we will always judge objectively, based only on facts, the truth, not possible truth or innuendo or opinion. Why? These things are based entirely within fallen human reasoning instead of God’s perfect judgments.

Well, there you have it. When this started, I had already been praying for many days that God would give me the wisdom and discernment in this matter that would glorify Him and edify the Church. The last thing I want is for the Body of Christ to be deceived one way or the other. Then as the “evidence” came in, I took it to the throne of Grace, asking God to direct my response to it. It was amazing how I could see the holes in the arguments. I had some good friends look at it as well. This was a good thing because that meant that I had other spirit-led eyes looking at this stuff. We should not be surprised my brethren when those led by the Spirit are in complete agreement on the source of these things and what is really going on here. This is why I wrote What Are Your Motives?

Let us stand firm my brethren against the wiles and deceit of the enemy. If the evidence I was given had clearly shown what was being contended then I would have had to respond differently to it. We must not cover up things like that. However, I did go through many weeks of severe doubt and anguish because of this stuff, but I took that to the throne of grace as well. It was through all of this that I was taught that controversies like this one are the product of people being used by our enemy to divide and confuse the Body of Christ. My doubts and anguish were the result of hearing the evidence without making την δικαιαν κρισιν, but I was κρινετε κατ οψιν instead. When I prayerfully came back to it with δικαιαν κρισιν I could clearly see that this was an attempt to deceive. Are you judging with την δικαιαν κρισιν my brethren?

Soli Deo Gloria!

4 thoughts on “Judge With Right Judgment

  1. Are you sure is my response to innuendo and speculation when it seems as such, my ears really perk up when a “they said” follows my question.

    The they said’s of this world can get you and them in a world of trouble! If you entertain them.

    I hope that this subsides for your mental health. A kingdom divided against itself cannot stand. At the end of the day, who’s bidding are we about?


  2. Though I don’t often comment, you know I always appreciate your articles, dear brother. It seems that these days, where truth is at a premium, even one’s zeal for truth can become a love for truth, making truth a subjective persuasion.

    When Gospel truth is subjective, the results are seeker sensitivity, purpose driven, market driven, subjective realities. Subjective truth will also obscure discernment to the other extreme, using truth to vindicate our thoughts and opinions, not only with regard to a favorable acceptance of seeker, purpose, and marketing methods, but also with regard to an unfavorable disdain for the same.

    When Jesus Christ, in His Person and His work (specifically His finished work at Calvary’s tree) is the object of our faith, then truth can be objective; and truly, I believe it can only be objective when He is the object of our faith, for He is The Truth. Therefore, we need, more than ever before, to cling that much more firmly to God’s grace found in Christ alone according to the Scriptures.

    I love you, my friend. Thanks again for your articles. My prayers are with you and your family as you continue to contend for the faith while edifying the saints.


Comments are closed.