13 thoughts on “Thirteen Heresies in The Shack

  1. I have been warning people about The Shack for the past month or two, and it amazes me how many Christians are still enamored by the book and they can’t wait to see the movie. It’s very disheartening. It doesn’t help, of course, when you have a lot of church leaders and “Christian” celebrities like Tim Tebow and Jeff Foxworthy praising the movie; nor organizations like CRU promoting the movie by giving away free tickets to see it. It sometimes seems to me that a line is being drawn with Christians on the one side, and the pseudo-Christians on the other. Seems like a great delusion is being sent to the pseudo-Christians. Hmmmm? I think I read something about that somewhere. Thank you for posting this Mr. Ratliff. I fully intend to share it everywhere I can.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Everything I post here automatically gets posted on Twitter and FB. Right now most of the response I am getting is on Twitter and here. We all have different sets of “friends” or followers. If you read some of the comments on the original post it is disheartening. However, I think this is an example of that line drawn in the sand God does, your know, that dividing line I wrote about a few days ago?

    Liked by 1 person

  3. When the book first came out I read a review of it made by a good Christian resource. He did not list this many, but he listed enough to make me put out some warnings back then about it. I have found that there are two types of professing Christians who are excited about this movie and have read the book. They are the biblically illiterate, you know, like those who follow Joel Osteeen. Then there are those who try to spiritualize everything while ignoring doctrine like the Gnostics. I read some comments today on this same meme on another site and it was alarming how many people claiming to be Christians were upset that we were taking this stand. These were the ones who base their entire Christian walk in Experiancialism …

    Like

  4. It’s like when Wild at Heart first came out. Or the Bible Code. Or The Matrix movies. Or Mel Gibson’s Passion. People in churches get SO EXCITED and fail to examine what’s being presented in the context of God’s Word. As you said, it’s the experience they get attached to. And that’s how people get converted to the papist religion or the religion of secret underwear.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. exactly. Another friend of mine said today about The Shack Book-> Objection: “It’s just fiction!”
    Answer: It is theological fiction – fiction written to teach a particular view of God and his relation to the world. Therefore while there are some things in the book that relate explicitly to the fictional setting, the explicit teaching about God in the book is intended by the author to be taken seriously.

    That makes this type of book and movie very dangerous as it is a snare to those who are not discerning.

    Liked by 3 people

  6. I am in the camp that is a work of fiction that grabs the imagination and inspires people to do some searching. Now, did this son of a missionary mean to present a theology? I think of Dante’s work that has no claim to Christian mysticism or theology but grabs the imagination for what us earth dwellers cannot fathom. There is danger everywhere – perhaps two larger dangers is assuming we are discerning while others are not — or the artist/theatre/literary/musically inspired, when motivated by their talent – choose not to express religous or spiritual content. The meme above is great as it points out succinctly where the work of fiction differs from Christology. I have not even seen the movie or read the book – but the meme prepares the potential viewer of the movie may present feel good drama but should not be interpreted as aligned with theology.

    Like

  7. Thanks brother Mike for posting this. So sad that many are spiritually blinded. Praying for God to give people discernment because so many are terribly blinded. Thanks for always giving out the warnings.

    Like

  8. Joe, perhaps, but I know way too many people who have little if any discernment and surprise, surprise their Biblical knowledge along with their knowledge of doctrine is slipshode at best. This type of movie and/or book is the worst possible thing for them to be exposed to. Hence the warning. That is my role and in obedience to it I post this sort of thing. I expect those with discernment to already “get it,” and they should in turn guide those immature believers away from such things that can only cause confusion.

    Liked by 2 people

Comments are closed.